Yep, the star ratings can't be any more than a 'guide'. When we were putting the book together we were less concerned with fine-tuning the star-ratings than we were with getting line-ups etc of 'known' records (although Anti-Social got found about a week after we went to print! Ouch!!) and discovering previously-unknown records. Basically, using the book in combination with GEMM/popsike will give the 'best' result of quite how rare something supposedly is. 'Supposedly' being an important word!!
If anyone is being prompted to put together a wants list based on 'new' stuff in the book, gimme a shout. I might have something.
Cheers,
Steve
www.lowdownkids.com