The "ban blahblahblah" thing is an old joke, for fucksakes!
I think that people argue about almost everything here. Pretty much all the bands Matt said were "hyped" just had long threads because most were making fun of them.
I know you weren't serious, it was used to illustrate my point, because I have seen shit like that written on here (not by you) when someone with a low post count tries to voice his/her opinion against the masses.
I agree with your second point, and I realize that half the Wavves thread is Arturo posting dog pictures and what not, but again, no publicity is bad publicity.
15 year old kid: "This Rusted Shut record looks awesome and the tracks on myspace are rad, I think I'm gonna paypal for it. Wait, the Vivian Girls thread has 90 pages, sure 75% is people hating on the band, and there sure are a lot of vagina jokes, but people do seem to care. There must be something important about this Vivian Girls record, better buy it instead."
Do you really think this doesn't happen?
I'm wearing my "Rusted Shut Kill" t-shirt right now because this kid decided to buy a Vivian Girls record due to the godfathers of termbo deciding not to offend one of their own's girlfriend.