wow... I remember going to Dummyroom a lot when I was bored and lived nearby. The cute chick working there (who I always thought was Joey's wife) actually recommended "Terminal Boredom" when I asked what was good.
Screeching Weasel will always hold a special place in my heart from being in my hometown (well, Chicago suburbs anyway) and for being the first punk band that really connected with me. Not best, but first. I was 16 and spinning through some metal and alternative stuff, and right about that time I borrowed Wiggle from a dude and can still clearly remember sitting in front of my parents' stereo and within the first ten seconds feeling that connect DIRECTLY and was like "THIS. THIS is what I have been looking for."
Of course that also happened with ska at that time. Hearing totally awesome, at that time still totally obscure music that was "underground" yet in direct contrast to the popular feel-shitty tunes of the time (Nirvana, Pearl Jam) was such a thrill.
Around that time I got MTX Our Bodies Our Selves which I thought was good and they kept getting better. I still think Revenge is Sweet is a great album. I think My Brain Hurts and How to Make Enemies are the best Screeching Weasel albums start to finish. Other albums may have better tracks here and there. The best 2/3 of Anthem are better...
I still like the Queers Love Songs for the Retarded.. I got to see them with maybe Rancid and the Voodoo Glow Skulls for $5 at Scrap Skate Park. Also spent a lot of time at Beloit Alumni House and of course Fireside Bowl.
I always loved the Mushugunas. My old ska band Greenhouse played with them at Off the Alley once. I always really liked all the Chicago punk bands as well as ska, but there didn't seem to be much overlap, or more specifically, punk bands seemed way too cool for ska.
Maybe it was me getting older or those bands getting worse or both, but none of the newer Queers, MTX, Screeching Weasel stuff sound very good to me. (I haven't heard much new Queers though.) My guess, which is definite idle theorizing, is that those bands really do think they're doing their best stuff now, and that's ok, good for them. I don't expect bands to crank out the same album over and over and have it be good.
Bands change and evolve and when they do it in a way you like (Registrators) they become way more than just a good rock band. And when they don't, they lose you, but I can still believe they are following an honest vision they believe to be best.