Yeah, I saw the Mistreaters play at tons of basements. Places that existed before the Punk Mahal. I saw them play at a basement in Butler, WI as a part of some BBQ party and it was the best time I ever saw them. The Punk Mahal always seemed like the "kiddie" basement to me, when several folks younger than me moved to Milwaukee and started that place up. I had been for years going to shows at places like the Earl House, the Oakland House, the Bremen House, etc... which was primarily a scene for sludgy Am-Rep-style bands. It was a certain group of people, and the Mistreaters played often to that group of people early on. The Punk Mahal was a different group of people - people who'd been into pop-punk and emo and shit, I think. Maybe I'm generalizing. So, it probably seemed weird for the Mistreaters to play there. Now, some of these groups of people have integrated more as people grew older, I guess. I dunno. Something like that.
Sure, I've had my ups and downs with the Mistreaters over the years. I had a period when AKE was sorta blacklisted from the Cactus Club, and the Mistreaters were the house band, so there was a little friction, but that was more backwash from the owner's attitude towards us and our rotten attitude and stage manners...
Kevin does a hell of a lot for bands in Milwaukee and is a nice guy who actually puts up with assholes like me!
I'm at lunch right now so I don't know how much of this I can comment on.
Clint, you're part of the basement scene, obviously. You probably live with people who are a part of that scene. Basement scenes are always about being friends and shit. What it boils down to is that it's like some of your friends didn't show up for your birthday party. It's you party. Cry if you want to and try to point out others faults in the process, but expect to get made fun of and hollered at for acting like a douche... I like you just fine Clint, but you set yourself up for this shit (probably on purpose, cause' you're bored)....
Also, you could point out that AKE doesn't play basements in Milwaukee often. Know why? Cause' noone's asked us in about 3 years! Know why? Cause' we don't hang around with the friendly pals in the scene very often...
I'll try to address your other concerns later...