I've got to say that I appreciate gurls' anti-punk stance, coming during an age where a lot of og punk stuff gets automatic praise and b-team bands from 76-83 are offered up as redemptive manna. I don't actually agree with maybe 90% of his tastes (Germs and Bags suck, well, ooooooo-kay on that one...) but it's as subjectively valid as Quasi-Young Steve's dismissal of anything that isn't based on the Archies sonic model. It's a take, you can argue it, and it keeps the ball in the air. Nothing more stultifying that uniform agreement.
However, I just have no doubt at all, not even a smidge, that as an 18-year old bopper I would've had a fuck of a lot more fun at a Bags show in 1978 than I would've at, uh, a Capital City Rockets gig in 1975.
And I suspect that a Hawkwind show circa '73 Space Ritual-era would've topped 'em both.
But where would a Rockin' Clones gig fit on this chart? Or a Berlin Brats? Or Thundermug? Or the Insults?