The Bags are great. What's wrong with you people?
We're heterosexual males. You probably like Bikini Kill.
In terms of it being "nice" that Collin's anti-punk or whatever the statement, no it's not "nice." The world is filled with genre queers, what I want (in terms of advice/reviews) is someone who likes good music across genres. I'm not going to sit around all day listening to "just" anything. These people are helpful in that they dredge and dig to the very bottom of the barrel, and while most of the stuff dug up is in fact the bottom of the barrel in terms of quality, they're able to hit gold that no one else would have taken the time to find (hence some great compilations / leading to cool reissues). What's "nice" about Collin is that he's a good sport when people give him shit and seems like a nice guy. And I'll bet there are a buncha of cool records at his house that I've never heard of.
Steve's taste is different from Collin's and completely illogical / all over the board. But Steve's a good shit. If he liked the Brainbombs we might consider making him a Knight of the Rock Table, but that seems unlikely. I'll have to talk to RFA about that one.
RFA once told me that he was going to make me a Knight of the Rock Table, but I guess I didn't pass the review process. Yes, it's true dudes, I've never owned a Brainbombs LP and hopefully never will. I am considering soliciting opinions as to what the best Black Sabbath LP is an buying it though. There's a Troggs tune that the dude who produced Black Sabbath produced, and it's got me wanting to give BS a try even though Ozzy is the singer.
As for what you're saying about Collin, I agree that his reviews aren't really that useful as a buyer's guide because he gushes over great stuff and total shit with the same unreserved abandon. However, his contrarian tastes always make for good message board argument fodder.