I just mean "real world pitchfork" in the sense that, the site has a pretty huge member list, and if people are downloading an album over there, it means a lot of people are hearing that album. I actually think of it as pretty good promotion for indie labels.
I guess I figure there are probably a lot of Pavement, Dinosaur, or Guided By Voices fans over there, too. Which I'm not saying is a bad thing, really, I'm just making a silly blanket generalization.
I'm also someone that buys a lot of records having never heard them, and as silly as it really is in 2009, I enjoy putting an LP on for the first time and having that whole experience. I definitely don't enjoy listening to rotten sounding records, but I guess the bad ones make the good ones sound so much better. Like buying those fucking Venus and the Razorblades records, and getting another record that doesn't completely suck at the same time.